Best pizza ever!! Worth every penny!! It was hot and the perfect temperature when it was delivered. Great for leftovers as well. The portion was perfect. I can't wait to come back to Columbus to order again and try more of their pizzas! I would recommend this pizza place to everyone! It was so delicious and fresh. Pizza is one of my favorites and this place is out of this world!!!
M
Mizan J
Local Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 1/8/26
• DoorDash order
10/10. Tonight was my first time trying the famous Jeb's Garden Pizza and it did not disappoint. It's my new favorite. Good leopard crust, fresh toppings, and generous slice sizes. So fresh. The one place where the food you get looks like the picture! I loveee Paulie Gee's.
D
Darren C
Local Expert • 36 contributions
Loved
• 6/23/26
• DoorDash order
My brother was hyped for the Hellified Porkpie White, but we both agreed the flavors just didn't hit as well as they should. 6/10
The Joe Peppitoni was absolutely incredible, and is probably the best pepperoni pizza you can get in the entire state. 10/10, absolutely get one ASAP.
J
Jamison L
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/5/26
• DoorDash order
Did a Trustfall with Paulie Gee and they let my ass hit the ground. Mushrooms on a thin layer of cheese and bread with a pencil thin drizzle of balsamic was not worth $24. I would order other pizzas from them, but this one gave me trust issues.
R
Randall W
Emerging Expert • 3 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/12/25
• DoorDash order
could have been better. very little sauce and cheese. Couldn't taste any of it. every bite tasted like chard bread. I love the taste of a chard pizza but with little sauce and cheese it wasn't a pizza. price was a little high. pizza was 22 plus delivery and tip and its 12in and very very thin and barley any toppings
