Peter and Brent Schepper opened Fratelli pizza in June of 2002 in a 550 sq. ft. space. They quickly won over the Flagstaff Locals and were voted Best Pizza by the readers of the AZ Daily Sun that yea…
Best pizza in Flagstaff. Crust is that perfect harmony of crispy and chewy. Great pizza ingredients. Amazing salad dressings too. Maybe best salad in town.
J
JL B
Local Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 11/15/25
• DoorDash order
Literally, I could stop ordering from anywhere else --- everything is delicious! The Pesto Cheesysticks are the best anywhere. The Route 66 is simply scrumptious and I just adore their Anti-Pasta (Small) salad! What an asset to Flagstaff this restaurant is!! Just GO or order now!!
J
JL B
Local Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 2/23/26
• DoorDash order
The Buffalo Chicken pizza was absolutely delicious! Spicy but not too, perfect amount of toppings and the blue cheese really adds to the overall taste. First time on the Full Order Wings ( 10 Wings ) and they were fantastic! First time for the Southwest Style Cheesysticks which were also a big hit. The Anti-Pasta (Small) is always wonderful and Fratellis doesn't skimp just because you're ordering small -- it's enough for two at least. Fratelli's has become our regular DoorDash delivery/pickup. ALL their specialty pizzas thus far have been truly GREAT! We're just aiming at this point to try every one!
J
JL B
Local Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 11/7/25
• DoorDash order
I thought I'd found the best pizza in town, but Fratelli's has squeezed them out! The Flagstaff pizza was absolutely delicious, perfect crust, toppings and taste. The Anti-Pasta (Small) was fantastic, even the next day. The Cheesy Stix were sooo tasty! Another thing to mention is the prices. I feel they were very fair and the portion sizes as well. You truly get what you pay for here. We will be regulars moving forward. Another BIG plus; the delivery person was on time, so the food was still warm. Great job DoorDash!
J
JL B
Local Expert • 32 contributions
Loved
• 5/10/26
• DoorDash order
Everything was delicious (except one)! Anti-Pasta (Large) & Spinach Salad (Small) extra fresh and tasty. Always like their Southwest Style Cheesysticks. Cheese Pizza (Large 14") and Cheese Pizza (Small 10") (create your own) were very good. However, I might tweak/add a few ingredients next time or stick with their specialty pizzas which are great everytime! Only small complaint, the Fratelli T-Ravs, were flat and nearly empty. Not the cheesy bite we'd hoped for.
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Specialty Pizzas
Some unique pizzas that our customers have come to love! Tastes to suit all your cravings!
Traditional Pizzas
The Classics using our homemade dough, hand tossed and topped with fresh ingredients and whole-milk mozzarella. Baked directly on the Stone in our deck ovens!
Calzones
Feeds 1-2. We stuff our pizza dough with lots of fillings and the finest mozzarella, then we bake it to golden perfection and serve it with a side of sauce.
Create Your Own Pizza
Homemade Dough, hand tossed, and topped with fresh ingredients.
Choose your Size and Pick your Toppings! All Pizzas come with choice of sauce and covered with Whole-Milk Mozzarella.
Appetizers
From the usual offerings of Breadsticks, Wings, and Mozzarella, to our more creative Arizona Style Cheesy Stix, we have something to please everyone!
Beverages
Salads
All of our salads are made to order with a variety of mixed greens. No iceberg lettuce here!!
Sweet Treats
To satisfy your Sweet Tooth. Made by Sweet Street.
