LARGE Round CLASSIC NYC: Great size, but needs more cheese and better treated sauce.
I ordered a large—it made more sense—and the slices were huge. Reheated, the crust was crispy, but there wasn't enough sauce or cheese. You should see more cheese than sauce, but here there was barely any cheese. I couldn't even taste it, which is disappointing for the price. Because toppings were spread so thin, the outer crust was too dry to eat.
The sauce also has a "straight from the can" flavor. Just a little lemon juice and measured sugar will fix that tinny taste. I want this local business to grow, but they really need to stop skimping on what makes pizza "pizza" and fix these inexcusable sauce and cheese issues.
I'm on Roosevelt Island; if I wasn't stuck home after surgery, I'd have taken the tram to Manhattan for a slice two blocks away. That’s why this was so disappointing. As it stands, I would not order this again. If this pie is proof of anything, size really doesn't matter.
J
Jackie G
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/7/24
• DoorDash order
Everything arrived ice cold. The order took almost 2 hours to arrive, so we were expecting it to be fresh. The Small Round CLASSIC NYC was completely burnt at the bottom. The CALZONE al FORNO “Magia Bianca” was ok but sort of bland. The CLASSIC PARM probably would have been good if it arrived warm. Very disappointed considering the price and very long wait time.
A
Alicia G
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/10/24
• DoorDash order
SPICY VODKA RIGATONI honestly wasnt spicy what so ever I might have gotten the wrong one. I feel like my expectations were very high for what I actually got. Not creamy couldn't taste the vodka. I'd say it was a 5/10 not worth the price tag a lot of room for improvement
K
Kristen B
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/27/26
• DoorDash order
Tastes great but for $28?? Absolutely not worth the price kinda ridiculous
