As the executive chef at RPM Steak and RPM, chef Doug Psaltis could be counted on to take much-loved dishes and tweak them into something memorable. This same skill is on full display at Andros Tavern…
Love,love, love Andros. Lamb chops and soup are to die for; tasty chicken; freshest salad in the city - generous portion, with herbs and less salty feta. Greek island quality!
Apple phyllo tart is quite delicious. We try not to order dessert but sometimes just can't resist.
A little expensive, but always a treat! Often have leftovers which stay fresh and delicious.
L
Linda T
Emerging Expert • 36 contributions
Liked
• 9/6/25
• DoorDash order
Everything is tasty at 5 stars and 3-4 stars for the Leg oF Lamb. However, the lamb was over priced at $40 for 3 small pieces or slightly over $13 for each little piece. The Fournou Potatoes had a delicious lemony flavor and the Kourabiedes was not drowning in excess sugar. The Ginger Beer is appreciated over soda.
C
Chelsey J
1 contributions
Loved
• 1/27/26
• DoorDash order
So yummy! Will absolutely order again. My salad is so fresh, and the chicken they topped it with is from a kebab! So much better than the sad grilled chicken I was expecting, and it has great flavor. And they threw in an extra soup gift! Yum!
L
Linda T
Emerging Expert • 36 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/27/25
• DoorDash order
The Gyro was very dry and hard. Hidden underneath the Gyro were hard French fries, I guess they were used as fillers. The Fournou Potatoes were burnt and I have had them previously. The potatoes are usually delicious so it was disappointing that I had to throw the potatoes and gyro in the garbage. The Kourabiedes were delicious as always and not too sweet.
M
Marisa R
Local Expert • 106 contributions
Loved
• 11/13/22
• DoorDash order
Excellent, as usual. Only complaint is that I wish the zucchini chips came with a larger side of Tsatsziki. It's such a small amount for a large portion and the cost of that item isn't cheap either. But the pitas are always like little clouds from heaven and the whipped feta is just so good!
