Almost didnt order because of the reviews but glad we did. Wings were crispy, pizza was great ny style thin and the chicken parm sandwich was a bit small but excellent. Id order again.
D
Dez K
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/5/24
• DoorDash order
Just bread and cheese for the cheese calzone, not seasonings or anything. It's just a pound of cheese wrapped in a thin layer of dough. And the small 10" cauliflower gluten free crust pizza we ordered had literally 2 pieces of pepperoni on it. Disspointed for an outrageous cost of $47. The only part of this that was good was the cauliflower crust.
J
Jessica C
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 2/2/24
• DoorDash order
Small Mac & Cheese with grilled chicken was good, basic, and comforting while I'm stuck sick in a hotel room. Grilled chicken was juicy and perfectly cooked. Cheese Ravioli
With sauce was good, but I would have preferred without the additional baked cheese on top. They gave me extra grilled chicken which was a kind surprise. The pizza Slice Neapolitan I ordered with extra cheese, extra red sauce, & pepperoni. It was great and the crust was perfectly stone cooked crispy, chewy, crunchy. I appreciate the personalized individual slice options & commend their business decisions as far as their online menu goes. Diet Cokehands were served fairly cold & you'll want to put them on ice when they arrive forgood measure. Tiramisu was excellent. Perfectly creamy, proportionate layers of flavor, & fresh. NY Style Cheesecake was great with a unique Grahamcracker crust that sets it apart from the competition as homemade with quality. Small Mediterranean was good, but I should have ordered a balsamic instead ofthe hidden valley ranch. Chocolate Chip Cookie was basic & descent.
M
Melissa R
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/7/25
• DoorDash review
we haven't had Anthony's for several months and in that time things have changed and not for the better. on the bright side they've updated their menu and there are several new salads. The down side is they are very expensive for the portion size...an Italian salad(substitute pepperoni for the salami)was $14 for a small salad. Their bread used to be a draw for me but has been replaced with cheaper bread that is not even as good as Kings Soopers garlic bread. likewise their marinara was awesome, fresh and chunky...now it is a runny watered down version. I hate to say it but we will not be ordering from them again, very disappointing quality for the cost!!
R
Rich S
Local Expert • 112 contributions
Loved
• 4/22/24
• DoorDash order
Whether it's pizza or pasta, I know I'm always going to get a good meal from Anthony's. Everything is just how I like it, 12" Neapolitan pizza crust not too thick or thin, sauce, meat, and cheese just right as it is, don't need to ask for extra. Garlic Bread with Cheese is really good too, not just re-purposed pizza crust, it's fresh bread with plenty of butter, garlic and cheese. NY Style Cheesecake for the win. I'm thankful to live close by.
