The PB&J taste just how'd you expect. Pretty good! Summer Island is light and sweet. Carlito's Way is absolutely bad :( it's super salty and the nuts overpower everything. We called to see if we could get a free smoothie because no one is planning to drink this one and the maker, Audrey said it's not good either. She said she's only made it twice before and also thinks it's gross. Which is partly probably why it came out bad. I don't recommend it and apparently neither does the staff lol Peanut Butter Energy Bites are very peanut buttery lol which I wanted so it's cool- Carlito's Way is the green one in the photo