What is the Bagels Your Way's address?

Bagels Your Way is located at 331 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766, USA. This is where you will go to get DoorDash Pickup orders, and where Dashers will go to get your DoorDash delivery orders.

Does Bagels Your Way offer delivery or pickup?

You can browse Bagels Your Way’s menu and place an order for both Delivery and Pickup on DoorDash. Bagels Your Way may also offer delivery and pickup on their own or through other delivery services.

What are the most popular dishes at Bagels Your Way?

The dishes most commonly ordered by DoorDash customers at Bagels Your Way are Egg Sandwich , Egg Sandwich and Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter.

Is Bagels Your Way a DashPass eligible store?

Bagels Your Way offers DashPass benefits like $0 delivery, reduced service fees, and $5 credits back on Pickup orders. If you want to know if a store is DashPass eligible, you can look for the DashPass icon next to their name.

Bagels Your Way

4.7Icon Loading(500+)•
Icon LoadingDashPass•
Bakery•

Store Info

DashPass

4.7(500+)•

$•Bakery

Our local Long Island community has been served with pride by Bagels Your Way Cafe. Bagels Your Way Cafe is the New York bagel cafe benchmark as one of the original "Bagel Cafes" on Long Island. Every…

Full Menu

closed

Featured Items

$0 delivery fee, first order

pricing & fees

to see delivery time

Featured Items

1 Dozen Assorted Bagels & 1 Half-Pound Spread

$25.00

•100% (7)

Create Your Own Omelet (Choose up to 3 ingredients)

$10.00

•90% (10)

Egg Sandwich

$8.00

•96% (127)

#1 Most liked

Create Your Own Deli Sandwich

$11.00

•100% (10)

Egg Sandwich

$8.00

•96% (127)

#2 Most liked

Bagel with Cream Cheese/Spread/Butter

$5.00

•93% (58)

#3 Most liked

Reviews500+ ratings • 10+ public reviews

4.7
Icon Loading
of 5 stars

A
Amanda G
2 contributions
Icon LoadingLoved
• 5/16/24
• DoorDash order

I've lived here for 25 years and bagels your way is always my go to! They have the BEST rolls on the island & the bagels are also delicious. I also highly recommend their baked goods and you can never go wrong with an iced tea. If you're looking for your new BECSPK place look no further. They've been in business a long time so that says a lot

J
J A
27 contributions
Icon LoadingDidn't like
• 5/18/25
• DoorDash order

Cream cheese not freshly made. Overowering scallions and vegetables must have come from a tub. Bagels looked promising on the outside but same fluffy white bread as everyplace else. Egg sandwiches were perfect and delicious.

N
Nancy J N
1 contributions
Icon LoadingDidn't like
• 4/2/22
• DoorDash order

Bagels good and cream cheese but egg sandwich wrapped in paper over flow over ketchup and ice cold maybe Foul would be a better option and less ketchup that doesn't leak and instruction for the sandwich read which were not

H
Hugh J
Emerging Expert • 44 contributions
Icon LoadingLoved
• 5/18/25
• DoorDash order

My new for breakfast they follow instructions and aren't crazy expensive

D
Dave W
Local Expert • 92 contributions
Icon LoadingLoved
• 7/3/23
• DoorDash order

Egg salad very good as usual; tuna salad tasty , generous portion; potato cubes as well 

Bagels Your Way

Featured Items

Featured Items

Most Ordered

Sandwiches

Bagels & Spreads

Breakfast Specials

Hot Fresh Sides

Homemade Salads

Catering & Large Groups

Bakery

Beverages

Most Popular