My Honey Glazed Salmon was cooked to perfection, the glaze could use some seasoning or heat to cut the sweetness in my opinion but it was very good! Wings were good but a little large for my liking.
P
Patricia F
Local Expert • 113 contributions
Liked
• 4/21/26
• DoorDash order
Not as great as I remember from a couple of years ago but still good.. Penne Alla Vodka was a small portion for the high price and was spicy.. Three (3) Sliders is a good choice to sample burger and they are
delicious... Mac and Mac and Cheese and Cheesesteak Egg Rolls were really good and enough to share ... will order again
S
Sallie J
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 6/13/26
• DoorDash order
Truly was surprised by how flavorful the Caswell Grilled Cheese was. And not even dimension that with the addition of the chipotle ranch with the sandwich, just took it to another level of flavor. The pulled pork on the sandwich was so delightful with the balance of the mac & cheese, and the chipotle ranch. Definitely a good surprise. Will fill you up for sure! 
F
Faris A
Emerging Expert • 25 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/27/26
• DoorDash order
The Wings 6 and Cheesesteak Egg Rolls were delicious, I was surprised at how good the wings were, I selected char and well done to ensure the crispiness. They got the charred part right but I wouldn't consider them well done, still doesn't take from the fact of how deliciousous the wings were. The egg Cheesesteak Egg Rolls we're tasty but small portions for an almost $20 dish, you basically get four smaller sized egg rolls cut into threes. (also time to change out the fryer oil) I will be asking for a refund for the side Brussels Sprouts, the description on the DoorDash app mentions "lightly charred and seasoned for a savory caramelized finish" does not say anything about bacon, whether it be an add-on or something you can remove, so unfortunately I had to throw them out due to it being cooked with bacon. I did go to the restaurants web page to see the description and it does mention bacon. Below the description it says "Generated by DoorDash using AI" so I am sort of not surprised
R
Ralph David F
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Loved
• 2/25/23
• DoorDash order
Its been about 4 years since ive had Caswell, and pleasantly suprised at how good and fresh everything was tonight. Fresh homemade chicken fingers. Well seasoned fries and tots. The mushroom swissburger had a lot of flavor while still being able to taste beef. The steak and blue cheese salad was super tender and one of the better salads ive had around town. They even put the meat on the side!
