Our old-world, Neapolitan inspired pizzas are slightly charred on the outside but light and fluffy on the inside. We use only all natural ingredients and are one of the few pizzerias in the U.S. that …
Really tasty but does this look like a 5 dollar plus salad? Does this look like a 23 dollar pizza? call it 3 dollars of ingredients and 10 in labor i was expecting bigger portions at that price point. even doubling their cost fair but its a little expensive. quality wise dough was undercooked in the center.
D
Douglas F
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/12/24
• DoorDash order
I've heard so much about citizen pie And how good their pizzasAnd how good their pizzas are? So I ordered a margarita pizza with pepperoni on it. And I was disappointed, first of all, the crust was so chewy, it was like eating taffy. The sauce was spicy. I've never had a Margarita pizza with a hot spicy marinara and marinara also had rosemary in it. I've never had marinara with rosemary in it. Only basil. The pepperoni was small about the size of a penny. But there's plenty of it and enough fresh mozzarella overall, I was not impressed for the price. And I definitely wouldn't order it again. Especially for twenty six dollars ridiculous
A
Amber S
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/3/24
• DoorDash order
This was honestly really disappointing. The crust was burnt to start, leaving a bitter after taste. The pizza didn't come with mozzarella which wasn't specified while ordering and they didn't at the burrata I paid extra for. The pizza was lukewarm and completely cold at parts by the time we got it, it was also completely limp and soggy. The sausage looked like gray crumbles of ground beef and was like cat food. With all the ingredients (PLUS a $5 discount) the pizza was $30, which is honestly ridiculous for what I got. Not worth it at all and I wouldn't recommend it.
B
Brianna J
8 contributions
Loved
• 9/27/25
• DoorDash order
They're pizza is so good. You can't go wrong with any you get. This one was so garlicky, which I love, but if that's not your thing- take note. Also, their crust is some of the best in Ohio, hands down, so the fact that this pizza is almost like garlic bread is a good thing. Overall, I'd order this again, but I'd add more toppings.
H
Heather P
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/18/26
• DoorDash order
Cacio E Pepe Pizza looked nothing like the picture advertised. I paid an extra $3 to add bacon and there was maybe 1 small strip cut up onto the pizza. there were only 4 small basil leaves on the entire pizza I also think they forgot to add the burrata. The Smoked Pepperoni Pizza also did not look like the picture. there was no lumps of the fresh cheese anywhere. Not a ton of flavr for either pizza besides black pepper. Thipizza. pretty expensive for incorrect/bland pizza. The Tiramisu was also very small for almost $8 and was very dry. Would not order again.
