A FAMILY OWNED RESTAURANT Welcome to Elm Hill Pizza, Southern Newington’s prime pizza place! Family owned and operated since 1975, we have been bringing our homemade menu to you throughout Newington a…
This is some really good pizza. Quality Ingredients giving out that Mom and Pop pizza shop cozy feel of home. 2 Items (Large) The sauce is quality and flavorful definitely a sauce I can never get tired of. The toppings have been all high quality. This place is onto something special here.
S
Si M
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/30/26
• DoorDash order
Pizza and French fries always taste phenomenal They literally never disappoints It's always enough to feed my entire family. I have picky eaters and they absolutely love it. It always comes fresh and I would absolutely order it every single time 
B
Brian C
4 contributions
Loved
• 8/14/24
• DoorDash order
Everything was good. Really like the way the chicken wings were cooked. A hint of heat (almost slipped past my 5 year old), but good flavor and really nicely cooked (not rubbery and not overcooked). Wings were all "fats", though.... my wife prefers the "flats" but I was happy. Steak and cheese: good. Bread is good, cooked nice, solid cheese to steak ratio. (Whole steak and cheese is a MONSTER portion). I would totally eat here again.
D
Damaris R
2 contributions
Liked
• 1 day ago
• DoorDash order
Elm Hill never disappoints! The pizza tastes great and the crust has the perfect amount of crispiness.
B
Bryana B
3 contributions
Loved
• 11/30/25
• DoorDash order
Ive been getting Pizza from Elm Hill since I was in Jr. High (about 30 years). Hands down the best pizza Ive ever had. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio lol. Family owned - they know what they're doing! We are also a huge fan of their Chicken Tenders with Fries, Motzerella cheese sticks, salads, garlic bread and grinders. It's a little tiny hole in the wall but dont let that fool you.