There’s a lot of good pizza in New York City. Not all rise to the level of greatness, but the pies at Emmy Squared do. Part of the beloved Pizza Loves Emily mini-chain, Emmy Squared, serves (yes) squa…
The Colony Pizza is exceptional. Love the square pizzas with the crispy edges! The Cheesy Garlic Sticks are also very good with crispy edges.
A
Akilah G
9 contributions
Liked
• 1/21/26
• DoorDash order
Both the VIP Pizza and the Cheesy Garlic Sticks were delicious. The regular size pizza is on the smaller side for the price but I guess you're paying for specialty. The VIP Pizza is unique and well worth the try. Feeds two at most. Both items tasted fresh even though they arrived less than hot. Overall I would definitely order again as a treat.
L
Lanette J
Emerging Expert • 27 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/16/25
• DoorDash order
Unfortunately, my pizza was sloppily prepared and undercooked. The grilled chicken was tough and had a weird taste.
Additionally, it was not the 8x10in pizza that I ordered and paid for. It was significantly smaller than advertised.
S
Shehzaib A
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/25/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered Nashville Hot Chicken Pizza and it tur out to be so bad. Chicken topping was all burnt. And it was not a topping they have just cut the burnt chicken pieces and put one piece on each pizza slice. Pizza was so oily it was looking like they have fried the pizza. And it cost me $37! You can have 100 times good pizza less than this price. Not recommended.
R
RODOLFO O
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/9/25
• DoorDash order
2 little peperonis per slice. So disappo Flavor is just alright. Hard to understand the flavors. Too little and too muh going on at the same time. Not tomention how overpriced this pizza is. Jets Pizza js way better for the right price.
