The food is excellent. The portions are large and worth the price. A good value. Last time I got a medium sized sandwich and it was very filling. I got a large this time to have leftovers but it's too good to guarantee that any is left for tomorrow.
J
Jennifer R
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions
Liked
• 2/24/26
• DoorDash order
The good: The Italian subs came well packaged, which I appreciated. The subs were made with high-quality ingredients and were absolutely delicious. I had it made on garlic bread which was wonderful. I got their buy one, get one free deal. I like the pickle spear on the side.
The bad: It was very small with very few toppings. If I had paid regular price for the sub, I would've been very upset. It was delicious, but definitely not worth that price. They didn't allow for special instructions, which I feel like any business that truly cares about their customer's experience would allow. 
I tried to compare it to Subway because that is my favorite sub shop. If you like lots of meat and fresh veggies with lots of options on bread, sauces, and veggies, plus want a good value, go to Subway. If you are more of a foodie and don't mind paying higher prices, have a smaller appetite, or don't like a lot of veggies on your subs, go here. They are delicious for sure but the cost (without the deal) doesn't justify what you get. If the portion wasn't so small or the price was less, I would have loved it rather than just liked it. With the deal, I would get it again if I wasn't that hungry. At full price, I'm choosing Subway every time.
T
Tara E
Local Expert • 123 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/5/25
• DoorDash order
The 50% off deal is great. Firehouse Meatball® was simple and hearty. I was worried there would be too much marinara but this one was just right. The sandwich rolls are soft and seemed relatively fresh. One thing I noticed is that their version of toasted seems to mean "steamed". I say this because my sandwich was warm and the cheese was melted but there was no toast or crunch. As my sandwich cooked down, the bread became a little tough to chew - like when you reheat a bun it creates a different texture upon cool down. The New York Steamer® was exactly as it sounds. Steamed sandwich. No surprises. The mayo is mixed in with the mustard so you don't get a true mustard taste. It would be nice if pickles and fresh onions were a choice in the modifiers. All this combined is what makes these sandwiches good - but not - great. I probably would order again if I pass through the area again
L
Lynne S
428 contributions
Loved
• 3/7/25
• DoorDash order
Firehouse Meatball® sub was excellent. Even better at 50% off.
I thought that it might be spicy because of the name. Then I realized that Firehouse Subs is the name of the restaurant. It's just a regular meatball sub.
Chips & Brownie were well worth the price. Especially the brownie.
P
Paige L
Local Expert • 40 contributions
Liked
• 10/21/25
• DoorDash order
Previously given five stars for their potato soup, which I've ordered a lot of times because it's so good. Today I ordered two and you could taste both were "old" and starting to be overcooked/curdling. Dropped a star for quality control.
