Decided to give them another shot. Cookies were perfect this time and none were burnt or greasy. Also decided to try other cookie flavors as well. Now, I see what the hype is about lol! Great for a cheat snack. My favorite flavor of cookies thus far are peanut butter cup, sugar, triple chocolate chunk, and snickerdoodle.
C
Chelsea A
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/23/26
• DoorDash order
The Summer Strawberry cookie was absolutely delicious, but sadly, it was wildly underbaked. I could barely pick it up. The eclair the day off cookie tasted good, but nothing spectacular. It was also underbaked (and I like my cookies to be slightly underbaked and gooey, but this was too much). The filling was more of a brownie consistency than a crème. The double dip crunch cookie was baked well, but tasted like a regular peanut butter cookie. I didn't get any chocolate chips or cone chunks in mine. It was definitely not worth calling it a deluxe cookie. Lastly, all of the cookies were quite small, not worth $4/cookie. I have never had a bad experience with insomnia so this was quite disappointing.
K
Kasey F
3 contributions
Loved
• 2/17/23
• DoorDash review
I was so excited for insomnia cookies to come to Brookings. So yummy & worth the money! I personally love the vegan confetti cookie.
J
Jessica B
27 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/25/23
• DoorDash order
The cookies were okay. A tiny bit burnt on the bottom but, it happens. Ice cream was good. The loaded red velvet brookie was good too.
