The margarita Pizza is the best in Bayridge and that is saying a lot so flavorful so fresh the portions are great and they are very consistent in quality and service and their staff is wonderful and easy to work with their chicken wings are also the best in Bayridge by far with those alone I am a regular happy customer if their prices are a bit high it is more than worth it like I say the best in Bayridge and their Caesar salad. It's huge. It's enough for two or three people. I've had many of their other dishes over the years I couldn't say more than they are the best pizza place in Bayridge.
R
Ryan L
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/27/26
• DoorDash order
Gluten free crust not good, ok toppings but not many given for an upcharged small pizza. Regular buffalo chicken pie was ok, not great crust and overpriced for the 12" size as well. Too many good pizza spots to recommend this.
S
Stamatis L
13 contributions
Liked
• 12/24/25
• DoorDash order
Their Bacon Chicken Ranch Slice is the best in bklyn and beleive me I've tried every pizzeria...regular cheese slices are great as well, but to offer a bit of constructive criticism, when I order their Cheese Slice by the slice and add on pepperoni for $2 bucks, they're a bit stingy on the amount of pepperoni added onto my slice; or maybe not; perhaps my dasher is opening my pizza box and picking off a few pieces and popping them into his mouth ...it's possible lol ....solution might be for Mancini's to use something other than a tiny piece of tape as a deterrent to prevent the dashers from even think about opening my box .....
S
Sheila R
2 contributions
Loved
• 5/13/26
• DoorDash order
Truly had a delicious take out meal on Mother's Day, no less. The meals were amazing in size, and they had great flavor! They were perfectly packaged and arrived piping hot! I know I will be ordering from them again, if not getting there in person! The family had lasagna, rigatoni with chicken in cream sauce, broccoli & pasta in garlic and oil. Everyone loved their dishes. Dad was the only one to finish off his lasagna dish, the rest of us had leftovers!
R
Robert M
Local Expert • 35 contributions
Loved
• 12/29/25
• DoorDash order
the baked Baked Ziti was perfect as was the Lasagna , both were cooked with care and with just the right amount of cheese. will definitely be ordering again !!
