totally totally loved our order I had turkey reuben, fantastic! potato salad best ever tasted . husband had chili and salad. loved it ALL. you get your money worth, peach tea soooo, good, thank you McAllister deli you are amazing!!
B
Bridge D
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 2 days ago
• DoorDash order
Ordered the Reuben with side of macaroni & cheese. The reuben was pretty good - not the best but definitely not the worst. It was over filled with corn beef which was great for overall value. The mac and cheese however was unfortunately the worst mac and cheese I've ever had. I didn't think mac and cheese could be bad (bad pizza's still pizza). This was different. Inedible. It was the blandest but also most chemically bad flavor. Very surprising and disappointing. Colossal Carrot Cake is decent.
N
Nicole H
7 contributions
Liked
• 8/3/26
• DoorDash order
Incredibly good! While the half sandwich was pretty small, I thoroughly enjoyed the pulled pork BBQ spud! My husband liked his French dip and potato salad. It was packaged well and still hot after being in the road for 25 min!
J
Jessica N
4 contributions
Loved
• 8/8/26
• DoorDash order
The New The New Yorker was packed with meat. my second time with you guys . This one delivery, still top notch. The only thing I would ask for is extra brown mustard! Delicious, excited to go to the actual store and get that new French dip soon. Definitely, recommend
K
Krystal S
14 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/9/26
• DoorDash order
The Smokey Pepper Smoky Pepper Jack Turkey is my favorite sandwich and they ruined it. The cheese was missing and there was barely any meat. They pretty much just sent me bread. I love McAlister's, but unfortunately it looks like the Gainesville one is going to suck. Don't know if I will order from this location again.