The Lemon Pepper wings were nice size and tasty, so were Piña y Habanero Wings. T are sweet and spicy with a slow burn. The 14" Traditional NY Style Pizza with pepperoni also delicious. I will order again try something else.
C
Chui A
7 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/3/26
• DoorDash order
Medium Ranch12" BBQ
ranch was not ranch it had a light yellow tone, and after tasting it, it was way too sweet. the 2oz portion cup was half filed in both of the "medium ranch" so another caution. either this ranch is not fresh or was made wrong or expired. (it used to be white like normal ranch.
the pizza was ehh...no spice level, little sauce could have been baked another 3 minutes as was very limp.
this used to be the place to go but after new ownership, price increases, no consistency and lowered quality stopped me from my 3x a week visits. my last visit was horrible a few months ago and decided to try again and only was worse. this is the last time I will order here.
I caution others as well.
quality, consistency, odd hours not worth the high prices compared to similar neighborhood pizza joints that out perform across the board.
J
Jack W
20 contributions
Liked
• 6/6/26
• DoorDash order
First time eating there. The pizza was really good I am not much of a pizza eater but it was really good. Ordered a side antipasto salad. Horrible!!! All lettuce for $10.00 would definitely order pizza again
J
Jenna K
5 contributions
Loved
• 2/8/24
• DoorDash order
Everything we ordered was delicious. When I'm craving pizza, this is exactly what I'm wanting. The NY 18" Traditional NY Style Pizza was fantastic. Big enough to feed the whole fam. Sonoran Pizza was hard to beat. Can't wait to try more
S
Sara O
Local Expert • 188 contributions
Loved
• 12/13/23
• DoorDash order
This was my first time trying My Slice of the Pie and I was not disappointed. The 12" Gluten Free was excellent. The crust was thin yet a little chewy and the edges were browned and really crunchy. The sun-dried tomato topping option is nice. Liked the different cheese options too, I did shredded Mozzarella and blue cheese. They were generous with the garlic, I could smell it before opening the box. I would have liked a little more mushrooms but no complaints, the pizza was great and I'd definitely order from here again. Hopefully they stay in the happy hour deal restaurants!
