Love this deli! I'm a New City resident and we love our local businesses who always take care of their customers. Bagels are delicious and the breakfast 2 Eggs Platter was flavorful. They kindly left me a note saying they ran out of the jalapeño bagels but they gave us complimentary jalapeños on the side. Make this your regular spot!
R
Ray T
Local Expert • 108 contributions
Liked
• 5/4/26
• DoorDash order
Their bagels saved this store from getting a 3 star rating!!
2nd order where the Beef Bacon and Egg Sandwich had chewy, inedible fat in the sandwich!
The "gourmet spread" I ordered was missing and replaced with plain cream cheese! :/
Their tasty bagels are soft and chewy with a nice bite, better than similar places with bagel in their name!
R
Ray T
Local Expert • 108 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/2/24
• DoorDash order
The pastramis is just like Katz's deli, over rated and pricey! It barely had any mustard on the sandwich, I had to add some from my frig! At least Katz gives you a humongous portion!!
They screwed up my order once again; order arrived missing fries and soda.
They also messed up and gave me a side of lemon poppy cake when I ordered pound cake! It looks like they took a slice from a store bought loaf by the way.
S
Saira V
13 contributions
Loved
• 6/10/26
• DoorDash order
Philly cheesesteak sandwiches are my favorite. New City Bagel has one of the best I've had. I can't wait to order it again!
B
Benedetta D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/21/25
• DoorDash order
Ordered C3. Boar's Head Ham and Provolone Cold Sandwich but got American cheese instead. It was ok. Satisfied the craving but not much ham and I didn't add mustard but I kept tasting it. Not sure if they used same utensils or something but that threw me off.