With over 15 years of experience, New Pizza Italia proudly serves Italian food made with fresh ingredients and time-tested recipes. Quality and taste you can count on.
The cheese manicotti and the calzone were incredible. Best calzone I have had in years. Will be going back!
H
Hilary K
Local Expert • 197 contributions
Liked
• 10/23/26
• DoorDash order
I usually order the spaghetti with meatballs. This time I had the rigatoni. I didn't like the flavor as much and the rigatoni overpowered the sauce. It's better with the spaghetti. They did include 4 meatballs this time. It's strange that the number of meatballs in this item the varies from 2-4.
S
Susan M
Emerging Expert • 21 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/23/26
• DoorDash order
I've always been happy with Pizza Italia, but this order was disappointing. The cheese pizza was undercooked, wasn't cut into slices all the way through so that I had to use a knife to cut the pizza slices apart. They also used a new pizza box that was flimsy and had gaps that allowed the pizza to get cold by the time I received it. The salad was very good and plentiful for the price. Hoping this is just a one off experience, and please go back to the old pizza boxes that are more solid and keep the pizza warm!
M
Michael D
3 contributions
Loved
• 1/26/26
• DoorDash order
This place is phenomenal! Ingredients are fresh and their pizza is made to perfection. Their salads are portioned nicely and again, fresh and crisp (no brown and soggy here!). While I have not tried them, the meatballs (2 pc), are rumored to be amazing. I absolutely will be ordering again, New Pizza Italia rocks!
H
Hilary K
Local Expert • 197 contributions
Liked
• 5/1/26
• DoorDash order
The Spaghetti or Rigatoni with Meatballs (I had spaghetti) was a good sized serving with 4 meatballs. It was tasty and a good value. The Italian Sausage Sandwich was mediocre. It should have had 2 sausages, not one split in half. I won't order that again. Nothing special about the Cheesecake. It was ok.
