Fantastic value with the two for one Create Your Own Pizza. Consistent flavor in all corners of this country. The medium size is a perfect portion, and the toppings are tasty and fresh. Will always come back to Papa John's and order again!
J
Jennica M
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Liked
• 3/30/25
• DoorDash order
I love the Create Your Own Pizza : 14" garlic stuffed with everything (pineapple, anchovies, Philly steak, mushroom, spinach, onion, black olives, Parmigiano, & don't forget the chicken for more meat, ranch, well done, clean cut), delicious! Needs a thicker crust option. The original was maybe a 16th an inch thick. Too weak, & not as filling, making you reach for more. Double the thickness, please! Nice Double Chocolate Chip Brownie . Soft. Maybe add some bread sticks for filler? Full hits your hard @ ~5 slices. Would be nice to fault at 3 instead of downing half a pizza mostly made of toppings. Expensive. Got 3 of these & the Brownie for 200+tip. Double the crust thickness would have made it more worth it, but the well-done option is crucial for allergies. Have a good one, all!
J
Jennica M
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 9/25/23
• DoorDash order
It would be nice if they included 2 sauce packets in an XL, and the option not to get a pepper as a garnish. Otherwise, best place. They have well-done baking, low nightshade sauce, and excellent pizza. Love the anchovies!
M
Melina D
1 contributions
Loved
• 9/28/26
• DoorDash order
This genuinely was the best pizza and garlic bread I've ever had. This was so fresh, I mean the pepperoni and spicy Italian sausage was absolutely chefs kiss. Who ever made this pizza and garlic bread deserves to be kissed by God himself. I hope a ridiculously rich sugar daddy/mommy comes into your life and bless you tremendously. As a college student, I don't get served pizza like this at my dining hall, so being able to have had this pizza was life changing. I'm still looking back at this photo, a few days after ordering and missing it like a desperate ex. I will definitely be ordering this again. This pizza has changed me in the best way possible. Thank you Papa John's....Thank you.
N
Noelani B
1 contributions
Loved
• 2/14/26
• DoorDash order
Five stars ts was literally the most equivocally bussing and saucy pizza I've ever had in my life. Plus I hate crust and I straight devoured the whole slice dude, 10/10, would roll up and shove my face here again. It was hella warm still when I pulled up and I was like 15 late I can't lie, and the small pizza was perfect for one person, so it was so gas, it was also ready incredibly fast so that was fire. Hell yeah
