Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs Is Here To Serve You.
Papa Kelsey's, your Mesa neighborhood pizzeria since 1992, is family owned and operated. We take pleasure in using only the best ingredients to make ou…
The pizza and the calzone, amazing. Every time we order from Papa Kelsey's the family is happy and satisfied. I wish the wings were more crispy but they are still very very good and I will definitely order them again. The marinara sauce is delicious and blended so not too chunky which I like. The blue cheese, very very good, chunky but not overpowering, perfect, love it. I can tell that they take pride in their work and I appreciate that so so much.
B
Braylon P
2 contributions
3/1/22
• DoorDash order
I don't like the wings very much.. tried them a few times but can't get on board. However, I order subs from them sometimes multiple times a week and absolutely love the meatball sub. Best for my money in Mesa.
P
Pamela B
97 contributions
1/6/22
• DoorDash order
I wanted to love the calzone. The top was beautiful & crisp. The inside was doughy, gummy and the bottom was totally mushy. There was hardly any flavor and what it did have was just strange, almost bitter. Even the cheese was tasteless. I would never order it again. Bottom of the cardboad box was nearly soaked though with grease. Yuck! Marinara tasted like it came straight out of a can with zero seasoning.
V
Victoria R
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
9/16/24
• DoorDash order
Pizza very thin, called ahead for extra tomato sauce , seems none extra. Wings tiny. Pizza tasty but not worth price. Wings either 🧐 Disappointed overall as I read great reviews before this, my first delivery/ order at all l... Called restaurant, merchant says extra pizza sauce, NOT. Food is chilly, no warming bag ? Will do a negative YELP, Travel Advisor reviews also.
J
Janet H
3 contributions
4/19/24
• DoorDash order
This was our 2nd time getting pizza, the first time It was really good. This time, not so much. it was cold and the crust was very hard. Very little sauce added. Very disappointing after the first experience. Giving 3 ⭐️ only because our first experience was good.
