Are you ready for a unique gastronomic adventure? Pellegrino's Pizza in Shoreham, NY is ready to accompany you on your journey! This Italian café is a terrific choice for anyone desiring a treat, with…
Pizza is pretty good, I honestly haven't had a great slice from anywhere in a long time but I order from Pellegrino's more often than other places so I guess that's saying something. The knots are just the way I like them, another review said they were undercooked but I like soft knots. The Godfather bread is amazing, if u haven't tried it I highly recommend that u do, the roasted red peppers and the spices they use really push this garlic bread to the top, after trying this there is no way I could go back to any other garlic bread.
C
Christopher H
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/26/24
• DoorDash order
Honestly way too expensive for only two little things of Spinach Manicotti. The garlic knots were good but the Spinach Manicotti was not worth the money i spent.
D
Donna M
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/28/25
• DoorDash order
I love their pizza but this one i was disappointed in. It was a one person pizza. It was a little burnt and the garlic and other topping was just plopped in half of it. So it was overwhelming like that. And thats my fav pizza place .
M
Megan H
Local Expert • 96 contributions
Loved
• 11/27/22
• DoorDash order
I've tried their regular, Sicilian and salad pizzas. All delicious - especially the Sicilian! And the veggies on the salad pizza are so fresh and plentiful. Super fast service. Great zeppoles and donuts too!
T
Theresa C
2 contributions
Loved
• 11/8/21
• DoorDash review
Best Pizza Around! Definitely the best knots!!!! Although the prices increased quite a bit. I suppose that's everything though sadly.