I absolutely love Penny Lanes Italian ice! It's one of those perfect desserts that hits the spot every time. The texture is wonderfully smooth, yet it still has that satisfying icy crunch. The best part is the intense, natural flavors and each one is so fresh and bursting with taste. It’s refreshing without being overwhelmingly sweet, and I love how it’s a lighter alternative to ice cream. The portions are generous, and it’s such a great treat for any time of the year! I’m definitely hooked and can’t wait to try more flavors!
C
Carrie C
5 contributions
Liked
• 2/16/26
• DoorDash order
Got a call that they were out of the flavor I wanted and received the cutest lil package. True water ices like back on Long Island and absolutely bomb flavor 12/10 this is my first order but certainly not my last
B
Briana M
4 contributions
Loved
• 3/26/24
• DoorDash order
Penny lane is INCREDIBLE . my best friend
Introduced them to me months ago and since then I crave it all of the time. unlike store bought italian ice, this has a softer consistency so you dont have to scrape it like ice. COTTON CANDY is by far my favorite flavor though cherry, rainbow, and BLUE RAZZ are also delcious.
M
Maverick D
9 contributions
Loved
• 2/3/25
• DoorDash order
Such an amazing experience! The ice was delicious and smooth! Not only that, they personalized the bag with a message, and gave a couple of samples of other flavors. I highly recommend the orange/vanilla and the cherry especially!
P
Peter R
1 contributions
Loved
• 2/7/26
• DoorDash review
Used to go almost everyday when it was at St. Peter's. The guy who ran it would give me free samples all the time bc I was one of the few ppl who first was trying it and getting his product out there. I didn't need to do much it sells itself. Very good and customer service back in the day was unbelievable. I still to this day tell as many ppl as I can about how nice the guy was and how good it is. He always gave me massive portions and it always tasted like it was supposed too. Peanut butter was my favor.