Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe
4.6(1k+)•
DashPass•
Italian-American•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(1k+)•
$$•Italian-American
Serving toasted sandwiches, pizza, salads, soups, and fresh baked cookies daily. Our locally owned and operated business serves the goodness of Pickleman's with fellow Hoosiers. We love catering to ou…
Full Menu
10:00 am - 9:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
#11 Italian Club Sandwich
$12.74
•94% (52)
#2 Most liked
#9 Italian Beef Sandwich
$14.20
•90% (21)
Pepperoni Pizza
$16.99
Sandwich Combo Meal
$14.31+
#5 Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich
$12.13
•93% (31)
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$20.03
Reviews1k+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
K
Katina T
Emerging Expert • 71 contributionsLoved
• 5/15/25 #11 Italian Club Sandwich was filledto the brim with meat and had flavor overload. I was stuffed after eating only one half of the sandwich.
S
Stephanie D
9 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/9/25The food was delicious, but one of our sandwiches fell short. I ordered the Asiago Chicken sandwich, which had barely any chicken on it. I piled all the meat on one side of the sandwich, and I ended up throwing away the other half of the bread. Plus, the sandwiches were pretty small. I order out quite often and don't mind spending the money, but this order felt overpriced for what we got. I won't be ordering from this restaurant again.
B
Beth D
7 contributionsLoved
• 3/3/26Fantastic in every way. Love the Grillos pickles and the BLT best. Consistently delicious and well packaged. Fast delivery.
M
Mike W
Emerging Expert • 16 contributionsDidn't like
• 8/14/25Order missing items, $12 BBQ mac & cheese is side item sized but good. Buffalo chicken sub no visible chicken or actual buffalo sauce... extremely unimpressed for the cost. Won't order again.
J
Jessica K
5 contributionsDidn't like
• 10/21/25The last couple times I've ordered, the Parmesan cheese in the small cup has had a strong smell and taste of mildew/mold. I think they are packing the cups days in advance allowing it to stagnate. Avoid putting it in your soup before checking it.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Toasted Sandwiches
All of our chicken and pulled pork is certified No Antibiotics Ever.
Pizzas
12" Thin Crust Pizza & 10" Gluten Friendly Pizzas
Salads
Available in Half and Full Sizes - Served with Dressing on the side
Soups
Available in 8 ounce or 12 ounce portions
Mac & Cheese
Creamy white cheddar mac & cheese
Sides
Beverages
Kids Menu
Choice of a Half Sandwich along with a side and drink.