have been using them for years. always hot, always fresh, and alot of flavor. I love pie guys. and my kids do too. highly recommend. first time with the Loaded Curly Fries and they were amazing. my 15 Wings & Garlic Bread were excellent as usual. and for 4 boys who are never satisfied they ate all the pizza you see missing and then some and then passed out!
I
Isaac A
Local Expert • 107 contributions
Loved
• 2/22/24
• DoorDash order
moved to CT just over a year ago and everyone has told me CT has the best pizza but I had yet to find a place that really sold me on that idea. this was the first pizza place in the state that absolutely floored me with how good the pizza is. the crust tastes like real dough, not a prepackaged dough product, the vegetable toppings were definitely fresh but ALSO cooked properly on the pizza instead being half raw and half burnt like other places. perfect sauce to cheese ratio too, and the pepperoni was both tasty and also didn't soak the pizza in grease. this is my permanent pizza place from here on out.
T
Thomas V
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Liked
• 11/7/21
• DoorDash order
The classic pie is a great value, essentially a 14" pie for $9.50. I add fresh tomatoes & mushrooms for a heavenly gourmet pie for $11 loaded with the extra toppings. Best pizza within 50 miles. The pasta with marinara has a great chunky tomato sauce that is sweet & not over cooked.
T
Thomas V
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Loved
• 10/25/21
• DoorDash order
I took a chance and boy, did it pay off! First, the best prices of Any Italian within 50 miles. More importantly, phenomenal food. I’ve worked in restaurants all my life. I’m from NY so I know good Italian. I had a 12 inch cheese pie, with tomatoes & mushrooms. I requested light cheese, heavy sauce, a light bake & soft crust because of teeth issues. Perfect. Look at the picture. Flavors were fresh and better than any of the 10 restaurants in my area (Wallingford).
I also got a spaghetti with marinara dinner. The sauce was full of tomato chunks, the way we did it in NYC. You need whole cooked tomatoes basically smashed to make this sauce. You can’t get away with just crushed from a can plus purée & paste. All the local places do that. Sweet & just about perfect. The pasta wasn’t over cooked which is another thing everyone does. Big portion plus garlic bread and side salad. Can’t say enough about this place. Try it. I guarantee you’ll love it.
T
Thomas V
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Loved
• 3/21/24
• DoorDash order
Love this place. Great price for a wonderful pie (the Classic Pie). Really Good sauce, which is a must, and quality cheese. I've worked restaurants all my life and I know quality. The Chicken Parmis very good. Tender breaded chicken, soft & flavorful, never dry. I get it all the time. I have to try other menu items which btw get great reviews, but their pizza is so good I have a hard time going with anything else! Lol
