Everything was so good! Highly recommend the Personal 10" Papi Pizza with a size of their ranch, which you can tell is house made.
E
Erika T
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/4/26
• DoorDash order
I wouldn't order from here again. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza ($33), a large Special ( Rotating ) ($37), and a garlic cheese bread ($19). The Gawlic Chez Bread is the only item I would consider fairly priced, or worth the money, it tasted great. The pepperoni pizza was extremely average, and prices are just not competitive enough. $33 for 8 squares of basic Pepperoni is ridiculous. I had higher expectations considering the price. The rotating special seemed to be based on Elote, there was corn and jalapeños and crema sauce, and cojita cheese. It was good as well, but again pretty average. If you're going to charge $30 to $40 for 8 slices of pizza they really should be something special.
K
Kasey F
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Liked
• 8/11/26
• DoorDash order
Precious Pizza has all the trademarks of a great pizza, but none of the things that back up said trademark. It LOOKS fantastic, it tastes mid. Cheese and pepperoni are above average flavor wise, but the dough on the pizza and Gawlic Chez Bread are incredibly under average. I would have been happy paying 25$ for this, but it was 50$+.
S
Sarah S
1 contributions
Loved
• 12/30/25
• DoorDash order
I must encourage you to order this pizza. Cast aside any doubt about price point, it will be entirely worth it and honestly comparable to your Papa's, your huts and other more notorious chains. Just do it. Just order the pizza. You will have no regret. Only joy and cheese.
C
Carissa C
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 9/2/26
• DoorDash order
I was so excited for this. I knew I should've waited until I could get down there. I got the 10” (small) Chez Bread and it was meh with chewy cheese. The cannoli was delicious and I wish I had 10 more. Also, as a dasher and a customer, packing needs to at least make the customer feel like the dasher couldn't just open the food. Simply tapping the boxes shut would go a long way.
