SO delicious! Finally a real Chicago pizza! We had the First Timer (Deep Dish) and the Chalmette Cheesesticks. Both were incredible. The pizza was an authentic Chicago deep dish (having lived 90 miles north and being a frequent visitor for 24 years of my life). I literally can't say that about any other pizza in the area. The cheesesticks were like a buffalo cheese dip on a fantastic thin crust. Will return!
R
Robert M
11 contributions
Loved
• 8/10/25
• DoorDash review
Excellent, excellent pizza probably the best I've had since I've been here. They did not skimp on any of the toppings taste fresh delicious and the crust is very good. Not like some of the other pizza restaurants here that have cardboard crust. I highly recommend it.
H
Harry M
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/6/25
• DoorDash order
not sure what was going on, but the pie was overcooked, little to no cheese and sauce. honestly some of the worst" Chicago" style, or pizza in general. all dough with little cheese and less sauce. totally disappointed. the fries were super soggy, under seasoned. and the salad was like 4 oz. deeply disappointed.
D
DD C
Local Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 11/13/25
• DoorDash order
I cannot say enough good things about this place! The Classic Chicago Cracker Thin (18"). is a masterpiece of pizza craft bursting with deliciousness in the form of garlic, fresh basil, and fresh oregano. My hubs is addicted to the juicy, smoky BBQ Big Boy Burger. that's stacked high with flavor (and just the right amount of heat). The Garlic Parmesan Bites. went perfectly with the crispy cracker thin pizza, as did the Side Salad (Caesar). which provided a nice refreshing balance to all the indulgence. The Chocolate Chip Brownie is absolute dessert heaven; it was not too rich or sweet, the crunch of the chocolate chips were perfect in the scrumptiously chewy brownie, and the creamy vanilla ice cream added just the right finishing touch. We will definitely be Rotolo's Craft & Crust regulars!
M
Michelle H
2 contributions
Liked
• 11/5/25
• DoorDash order
Overall our experience and order feedback was positive. The salad was fresh and abundant and well dressed. The Big Apple (Deep Dish). was the first time we've tried a deep dish and we really enjoyed it. Our only qualm was it was no longer hot. You can really taste how fresh the ingredients are though. The Chicken Alfredo. was very bland, but the packaging kept it nice and warm. The true favorite of ours was the Boudin Balls. They're so unique for the area and DELICIOUS!
