Sam and Mary Rulli have made Middlebury their home for more than 20 years. Sam began 33 years ago at his parents Marylou and Pasquales' restaurant, Pasquale Rulli's, in Mishawaka, Indiana. Since then …
The food here is amazing. The Stuffed Breadsticks are perfectly seasoned and crispy. Everything we've ever ordered has been delicious.
Tammy M
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 12/2/25
• DoorDash order
Rulli's awesome "don't want to cook today!" Cheese Pizza (12"-8 Slices) is always great! So are the Side Sauce Choices Breadsticks w/alfredo!! We dunk almost everything in their Alfredo it's so good! But check out this calzoneCalzone & SauceCalzone & Sauce (12") ! They are HUGE!! And when you cut a piece the cheese just bursts out! And surprisingly not kinda greasy like ALOT of calzones are!
D
Devin L
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/4/25
• DoorDash order
The breadsticks were so overcooked I could barely eat them. Chicken Parmigiano tasted good but the chicken could have been bigger compared to the huge pile of pasta. But in all was pretty tasty. Alfredo wasnt anything to write home about either. Pretty standard. Prices are pretty heavy too.
Tammy M
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 9/9/25
• DoorDash order
Rulli 's has the best Calzone & Sauce (12") !! They are DELICIOUS, huge, packed and cooked perfectly! And don't forget to order some of their 8pc Garlic Cheese Bread too! it's SO GOOD too! Enjoy!
C
Cheryl B
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/10/25
• DoorDash order
Very disappointed with the chicken bacon ranch sandwiches....no chicken on the sandwiches to really mention and NO ranch dressing whatsoever. The salad was "meh" with barely any chicken and the lettuce was iceberg which was also disappointing. SO...$120 for a pizza which was also sub-par, 2 horrible chicken bacon ranch subs, a terrible salad, a kids spaghetti, and 6 fried chicken thighs which were the best part OR I should say the only good item from the order. Sorry guys but this was not at all expected! Definitely deleting this restaurant from top 20 list !
