Sammy's Pizzeria
4.3(3k+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.3(3k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Family owned and operated for 3 generations since 1962. The originators of the "1/2 Tray" of pizza 🍕 Proud to be featured at Highmark Stadium for our "Buffalo Bills" Pizza! Winner of the North Easter…
Full Menu
11:00 am - 12:10 amFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
1/2 Tray & 20 Wings
$50.59
•76% (34)
Half Tray 15 Pieces with Cheese
$18.95
•83% (217)
#1 Most liked
Full Tray & 30 Wings
$81.09
•90% (11)
Full Tray 30 Pieces with Cheese
$35.95
•96% (27)
1/2 Tray & 10 Wings
$34.29
•100% (17)
New York Style Pie (Medium)
$15.95
•86% (60)
Reviews3k+ ratings • 200+ public reviews
4.3
of 5 stars
J
James K
3 contributionsLoved
• 5/20/23It was very good!, I got 1/2 Tray with Cheese + Pepperoni. x20 wings Extra Crispy, was made very well and flavorful, the wings were really crispy, and still tender and juicy inside, also they were big wings, definitely worth the price!
B
Brittney H
7 contributionsLiked
• 3/20/2614 Buffalo Wings were crispy snd perfectly done.Mozzarella Sticks (6) were also cooked perfectly my son loved them.Sammy's Salad devicious as always especially the homemade italian dressing. 10 out of 10!!!
B
Brandy D
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 3/19/25Lemon Pepper chicken finges were very small and thin.....Salads in dinners were horribly put together, next to no lettuce at all. Called to share my concerns and was told this is the size of the salad. Order from here often but quality seems to be dropping. Not to mention customer service! Completely disappointed
Blue Cheese & fry in pic to show scale/size of chicken finger.
C
Cyndi R
Emerging Expert • 5 contributionsDidn't like
• 1/31/25does what they sent me look like the pic of the cheese bread in pic, some were burnt, n some hard like a rock, like coming from microwave, was terrible to go with 3-4 leafs of lettuce for 9.+ dollars just a shame, I know times are bad but you eat with your eyes .
N
Nathan S
4 contributionsLiked
• 7/3/25If you know Sammy's you know the foods killer, pizza with a sweet sauce and a garlic crust, my god it's good. Only complaint, and I can't even blame them for this - half tray, couple toppings and some wings (free delivery) with a tip, and we topped out at $78.00. Again, can't even put all that on them, they work hard. But that's where we're at. Crazy times
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Appetizers
Original Buffalo Wings
All served with celery and bleu cheese.
Chicken Fingers
All served with celery and bleu cheese.
Salads
Sizes: small and large.
Everyday Specials
Pizza - Niagara Falls Style Trays
Pizza - New York Style Pies
Specialty Pizzas
All specialty pizzas can be made with a ranch, bleu cheese, nacho cheese sauce, white or classic red base.
Pizza - Gluten-Free Pizza
Stromboli & Calzone
Pizza - Chicago Deep Dish
Subs
Imported four seasons bakery rolls.
Hot or Cold Sandwiches
All sandwiches are served on Italian bread and include chips and pickle.
Pizza - Detroit Style Pizza
Crisp cheese crust, thicker airy dough wish sauce layered overtop if cheese and toppings
Wraps
All wraps are served with chips and a pickle.
Pizza - Stuffed Crust Pizza Pies
Cheesy mozzarella stuffed crust pizza!
Pasta
All pasta dishes served with garlic bread & side salad.