The Santeramo Family is honored at Santeramo's Pizza House & Italian Food. Michael Santeramo and his wife Catherine are both Italian immigrants. Lawrence, the oldest of their five children, married Ju…
First of all, that Chocolate Explosion Cake.
Wow.
I usually get the calzones from here and they are by far the best ive had in Greeley. No contest.
L
Lori S
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
Loved
• 6/30/25
• DoorDash order
the cannolis are homemade and amazing! the Calzone was huge and each bite full of flavor! they did a fabulous job on the homemade pasta andt the meatballs were as big as a baseball!!!! this was our first time ordering from here and I promise it won't be our last. everything was very delicious.
K
Keo D
Local Expert • 103 contributions
Liked
• 2/8/26
• DoorDash order
the smallSmall (12") is actually enough for 1 or 2 people imo. the crust is thin and cracker like on the ring. but not fully. the toppings and cheese are all very good and above chain pizza places. a little pricey but most are. even chain ones. quality toppings though. the Hand-Crafted Sausage was good, but would've been nicer with char.Santeramo's Signature Sauce is by far the least appealing thing. it may be quality. but it taste generic and or not good to me. if they use this on the pizza. it taste good there. maybe cause it's cooked or baked in. Calzone was good. the chicken i added was real chicken and juicy. did lack a flavor. more just decent chicken. and it's filled well. Tiramisu was very soft and creamy. but to me. too pricey for what you get. so if I did get food here again. I'd just stick with the pizza.
D
Deana B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/18/26
• DoorDash order
The Bucket of Spaghetti was not as pictured. We received linguine that was not the homemade noodles we have gotten here and what is pictured in the menu photos. Very over cooked and disappointing. Also did not have much sauce. We ate the meatballs off of the top and left the rest.
A
Abigail D
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/28/24
• DoorDash order
The spaghetti is absolutely terrible! The noodles were overcooked and mushy and there was not nearly enough sauce. The sauce is bland.
Garlic bread is severely lacking flavor, however the cheesy garlic bread is good. I have had better, but it was good.
Meatballs were definitely the best part of the meal, but again I have had better.
Save your money and get spaghetti from the grocery store.
