If you like BIG cookies, these are great. They're like a quadruple size cookie. They are not, however, like the stuffed/frosted cookies you see elsewhere. These don't come warm and they are individually wrapped in plastic. Their flavors are basically additional chunks and very sparse filling. These are pop tarts compared to toaster strudels. That shouldn't keep you from ordering! I loved the cookies . I was just expecting more of the big gooey center and these are just more evenly mixed. Think double stuf compared to regular, but twice that or more!
G
Giovanni T
1 contributions
Didn't like
• today
• DoorDash order
My cheat meal was ruined they are not buttery or chewy it was like biting into a nature valley bar very crumbly. Although they are big, more of something that's bad doesn't make it good Butter Pecan cookies stay top Tier cookies
J
Jasmin C
8 contributions
Loved
• 9/5/26
• DoorDash order
There was a comment that said they thought the cookies would be bigger and I kept that in mind and was like damn do I really want to spend that much and have it be small? But I did it anyway! And I'm glad cuz the cookies were huge idk wtf they were talking about.
S
Sarah S
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Liked
• 7/23/23
• DoorDash order
While we loved the cookies, we were expecting larger cookies based on price and picture. The Caramel Oreo Crunch and Campfire Smore's were delish...just small.
A
Amanda C
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/9/24
• DoorDash order
I loved that these cookies were individually wrapped, were a robust size, and there is a variety to choose form. However, while they are definitely sweet, that's kind of their only note (at least with those I ordered) and they are not as soft as I would have liked (although I ordered later in the day so perhaps mine were sitting for a while and dried out a bit). The apple pie didn't do it for me and the salted caramel brownie cookie could have used a tad more salt (or maybe some flaky salt topping) to offset the amount of sweet. I really enjoyed the campfire smore's cookie, though. Overall, 3 stars and I would definitely go back to try their other flavors of which they have a great variety!
