Tony Boy’s Sandwich House is a gourmet sandwich shop with two locations in North New Jersey. Originally founded in 2017 to satisfy the yearning for a quality sandwich shop that didn’t leave you feeli…
Everything had really good flavor, probably liked the eggplant the most! The cheesesteak was exceptional with the peppers but it was too much bread to meat ratio. That's really our only complaint for the parm, doozer, and drunken. But again, flavor was spectacular!
D
Danielle D
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/4/26
• DoorDash order
I received a 7 inch sandwich and I was charged $20 not including the tip. The bread was so hard I could barely bite it, the restaurant did not accept any special instructions and all I wanted to ask for was extra mayo. On the site, I did not know how large the sandwich was going to be, and I was extremely disappointed.... I would not order this again.
A
Amy W
Local Expert • 37 contributions
Loved
• 6/26/24
• DoorDash order
I'm impressed with this place. I've ordered 3 times just this week for myself and my husband since our fridge broke down. Chicken cutlets are the right size, thickness, seasoning and not dry. I love the chicken parm and lumpy, hubby got the dodger, all very good, chocolate cookie and fries are also solid. It's a big footlong so worth the money.
I
India A
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/6/23
• DoorDash order
Tried it for the second time. Fries were over cooked this time 👎🏾. The bread is way too hard as though they leave it uncovered which just drys the bread out. I also just wanted oil and vinegar not Italian dressing because that's what it tasted like👎🏾. Overall not satisfied, it was miss for me. Longfellows in Morristown is a better choice 🤷🏾♀️
G
George Y
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 5/4/22
• DoorDash order
What an incredible experience this was.
Perfect salad, good amount of dressing, and a unique way to present croutons. Perfect appetizer and it really was refreshing and fresh.
The fries were seasoned well, nice and long but... the paper bag they came in made them just a bit soggy. But it's totally not a problem given their perfect flavor.
Burgers were beyond perfect as well, cannot complain, would recommend all of these even the fries. Great place, great job guys!
