Vinny's N.Y. Pizza is transitioning to Fire & Stone New York Pizza Kitchen. Same owners, same recipes, same people, same love for pizza!
Follow us on Instagram!
Out of towner here. Pizza was pretty good, just what iwas looking for- NY style and not spicy. Cannoli were delicious with lots of filling and good size for price. Best part of the salad was the cheese and dressing. Soda was a bit overpriced. Expected a 2 liter for $4.50 (menu didn't specify) but it was a 20 oz.
J
Jasmine D
5 contributions
Loved
• 2/23/26
• DoorDash order
Pizza is top tier NY style pizza but it was a bit on the small side of what I expected. I thought a large is standard NYC slice and a smaller was a regular pizza I've. These were like a medium size slice. I'll definitely get large going fwd.
Sauce is excellent. Flavorful and a tad sweet. Perfect.
Salad was a great portion and full of fresh veggies.
R
Roger H
Local Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 5/11/26
• DoorDash order
Traveled from Las Vegas to Atlanta and was lookng for a good pizza place. Vinny's had a 4 star rating so we decided to give it a try and was not disappointed. The Pepperoni Pizza slices were huge and very good. The Honey flavored Baked Wings were out of this world. For dessert we ordered the Lemoncello Cake was to die for. If you're in staying in Midtown Atlanta, you have to try Vinny's!
N
Nicole G
2 contributions
Loved
• 10/20/25
• DoorDash review
I'm at hospice with my grandfather as he passes and this has been the worst week of my life. I finally ordered a real meal for the first time this week to the hospice. I ordered the deli calzone with a piece of "tiramizu". It was fresh, the portion was so big that I still have plenty to eat again today. The ingredients were high quality and I don't live in this area but I would 100% order again. Everything was great and it was surely comfort food in this difficult time.
N
Nike S
42 contributions
Loved
• 10/5/25
• DoorDash order
Very good quality food, fresh ingredients for sure. My Cheese Calzone was a great portion size, NY Cheese Slice was fresh just like NY and the Caesar Salad* was on the money
Oh yeah the Limoncello Cake was really nice, light and airy even
