Wally's on Broadway is the home of the #BUFFALOPIZZABEAST! We use the highest quality ingredients prepared with uncompromising standards! 50% meathead 50% pizzageek 100% Buffalo Pizza Beast!!!
I will say that the pizza exceeded my expectations. I tried wallys pizza when it first kicked off and it wasn't a goodpie. to doughy, not done all the way and bland. the NEW changesthey made to the name also applis to the food. I recommend giving it a gothe crust was crispy but in the best way. pepperoni was generous and the cheese was cheesing lIke Iwas after I ate 3 ppieces of pizza to the face. I will be back, expeditiously.
A
Alessandra G
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Loved
• 8/14/25
• DoorDash order
Wally's is hands down, the best pizza. Clearly made with love every single time, his pizza with sweet red sauce and that hot-honey drizzle is heaven on earth.
J
Jeremy L
Local Expert • 73 contributions
Loved
• 10/25/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza was slightly well done as requested and these medium wings with their 3 oz. unique homemade blue cheese are fantastic - def will order again l. 10/10 for a 2am DoorDash to work.
D
Desteny W
Local Expert • 70 contributions
Liked
• 2/16/26
• DoorDash order
This Small (1/4 Sheet - 6 Slices) was fantastic! Sauce was amazing. Lots of cheese. Fresh ingredients. Perfectly cooked. Can't wait to order again!
C
Christopher M
49 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/5/25
• DoorDash order
I did not like the pizza but the wings were okay. This is Wally's Pizza Cafe, which I find a bit misleading, unless Wally's went out of business they should not represent themselves as a different entity for DoorDash, as I know I had tried Wally's pizza and didn't like it. It was doughy which is fine, but it was not cooked well and the crust was not crispy at all. 1/4 Sheet Cheese Pizza & 1 Topping, 15 Boneless or 10 Regular Wings would have been a good value if it had been good.
