Literally ordered the same thing the other day and it was so much better when the other crew was on staff. This time it was soaked in cream cheese, not enough ingredients; not enough salmon, lettuce, etc, and absolutely zero capers. Don't like how they skimped so much this time. Portion size was super small compared to a couple of days ago but probably not a management issue more like staffing issue. The bagel was overly toasted and hard. There was so much cream cheese on the single shred of lettuce I had to remove it. The weekend crew doesn't know how to make bagels. I'll be sure to avoid ordering on the weekends.
M
Meg J
1 contributions
Liked
• 4/11/26
• DoorDash order
Main Street bagels is thebest. I send my brother the Vegetarian with Hummus almost every day at his post acute Center. He loves the homemade Hummus and he is very picky. It is also so helpful they have Fruit Smoothie. They are very considerate and I really love giving Main Street Bagels my business!
E
Elan W
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/31/25
• DoorDash order
What a rip off! Says they are 80% less expensive than others but a single bagel is $3.50. Izzy's is $2.95 and Boichik is $3.00. And their bagels are mediocre at best. I'm very disappointed.
J
John B
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/13/24
• DoorDash review
I just enjoyed the Turkey sandwich on a wheat bagel and a coffee latte with Italian syrup. I wish they opened earlier. Their breakfast selection runs circles around the Starbucks next door and the coffee latte I had was definitely better tasting than the Starbucks next door. My day starts at 6am and unfortunately I can't enjoy Main Street Bagels more often. This would be my daily morning stop if they opened at 6am. Glad to see the small mom and pop stores still around and I try to support them as often as possible.
K
Kathy L
181 contributions
Loved
• 1/12/24
• DoorDash review
First time trying Main Street Bagels; I thought I was ordering fr Bagel Street Cafe!🤪 Only tried the sourdough one so far, but it was a 12 out if 10! Still warm, slightly crispy exterior, soft & slightly chewy in the inside. This is how I like/LOVE my bagels! Not a mistake; jt was "divine" intervention!😉
Thank you for obliging me with the special instructions, too!!! ♡♡♡
