O'Keefe's Tavern
4.8(50+)•
DashPass•
Irish•
Store Info
DashPass
4.8(50+)•
Irish
Full Menu
11:00 am - 9:10 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Irish Puffs
$13.49
Shepherd's Pie
$19.49
Fish & Chips
$21.49
Reuben - Corned Beef or Turkey
$18.49
Potato Skins
$12.49
Corned Beef & Cabbage
$19.99
Reviews50+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
J
Jen G
Local Expert • 342 contributionsLiked
• 2/15/26Shepherd's Pie was delicious but looked like slop in a pan. I guess they screwed up the order & just dumped it into the pan. It still tasted good but the meat was separated from the rest.., kinda odd. It was fresh & flavorful & we will order again. I just hope management intervenes soon. I could see them crashing soon if not. Our order was late due to the restaurant not making it in a timely manner. Also, for $20 the pan should have actually been full...
J
Jen G
Local Expert • 342 contributionsLoved
• 6/2/26Food was great!! Chicago beef is very tender & flavorful. Thank you for putting the fries separately they arrived hot, fresh & crispy. 10 stars!!
J
Jen G
Local Expert • 342 contributionsLoved
• 9/29/25We haven't had O'keefes in years so when I saw them in DD, I had to order. We tried the Irish Puffs. They were definitely different but good. They're much smaller than they look on the menu but bursting with flavor & quite filling for such small things. The pastry on the outside of it was fresh too. I definitely recommend trying them.
We also orders a full pound of Chicken Wings & Boneless Bites - Boneless - medium. I love that they are not breaded. It makes them more flavorful. We requested both ranch & blue cheese. They included it no problem.
I did not realize the chicken came with fries so we ordered an extra side of Frenc Fries. I still recommend do this because the side of fries were hot, fresh & crispy. They were the battered fries. The fries with the wings were soggy. I wouldn't have minded if they were in wing sauce but the sauce was kind of lacking. It's ok I have plenty of sauce to add to the chicken.
I'm glad to see them on the app & will definitely order again.
J
Jen G
Local Expert • 342 contributionsDidn't like
• 10/6/25Tonight wasn't the best for this store. I did not realize they closed so early on Sunday or I would have ordered from another store. The food was still good but it was obvious they were not paying attention. We ordered Mediterranean Chicken cooked in white wine sauce with veggies & a side salad. It arrived as a piece of chicken on top of a salad. It was still good just, not what we ordered. The Mulligan Stew was delicious however I did find a huge chunk of gristle & a couple bone fragments. The Nachos was a very tiny portion for $12. It was about the size of a order of nachos from Taco Bell. There were quite a few toppings on these nachos, though, which made it sufficient for the chips. I just wish we had more chips. The nachos seemed a bit soggy, not very fresh. We have thankfully dined here so many times over the years that I know this was an off night for them. Maybe they were just ready to close, maybe they read the order wrong? I'm not sure. We will still order again. hopefully next time we can order a little earlier & receive freshly cooked food.
S
Samantha B
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 6/30/26Reuben Egg Rolls were over cooked and the portion was very small.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap had so much sauce it all fell apart
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Starters
Soups
Salads
Salad dressings: avocado ranch, Caesar, bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette, ranch, 1000 island, honey mustard, and oil and vinegar.
Sandwiches
All served with a choice of coleslaw or fries. Pickle on request. Sub sweet potato fries, onion rings, or onion straws for an additional charge.
O'keefe's Classics
Add a side salad for an additional charge.
Burgers
Entrées
All entrées served with a choice of one side: baked potato, fries, rice, veggies, mashed potato, garlic bread, coleslaw, soup du jour, house salad or house Caesar. Upgrade to premium side: sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional charge. Add house salad or soup du jour for an additional charge.