Toto`s Restaurant & Pizzeria was opened in 1932 by grandparents Caroline and Antonio (Toto) Spadarella on Coney Island Avenue in Brooklyn, both from Naples, the birthplace of pizza, with huge stones. …
Best Pizza on the Peninsula! Cheese is tasty, really good Caesar salad, and the garlic cheesy bread is on a fresh sourdough, so good
L
Larry C
Emerging Expert • 59 contributions
10/21/24
• DoorDash order
not sure why this place rates 4.7 ... pizza was at best mediocre ... the only flavor present is that of all the jalapenos on the pie ... the rest is bland worthy of a chain like Dominos or Pizza Hut ... very disappointing and not worth the money ... try somewhere else
K
Katherine G
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
8/18/24
• DoorDash order
I used to like totos! Never again. I got the large combo for 4 people. No one liked it. It was flavorless and overcooked. The cheese was hard. It was gross. We had over half a pizza left and threw it away. It was horrible
The Caesar salad is good. No complaints
The minestrone is garbage. Tastes like watered down tomato juice and dish water with loadsof beans and noodles.
All this for 80 dollars. Never again!
M
Matthew D
57 contributions
1/18/23
• DoorDash order
Minestrone Soup was surprisingly bland. Had no beans and very little macaroni. South city Meatballs and ravioli was tasty, and came with a huge salad on the side. Dressing options were a bit disappointing though. Accompanying garlic bread was a generous portion and also tasty.
S
Soledad M
Local Expert • 78 contributions
1/17/25
• DoorDash order
Medium #3 is usually awesome, but seems like the cheese & sauce ratio has been off lately. Plus the traditional crust used to hold up. San Bruno location Pizza a la Toto's No. 3 Small/Medium keeps it traditional.
