In 1991, a small group of seasoned pizza chefs observed that Madison's pizza options were inadequate. PIZZA EXTREME was founded on the ideas of these dedicated individuals. Only the highest quality me…
Not a fan of the Spinach Cheese Bread but the Chicago Style Stuffed Pizzas (Medium-11in) was FIRE!!!! I'm a Chicago Italian and I don't think 5 stars rates this pizza high enough. We got the sausage with extra cheese and IMO extra anything is not needed. The sausage tasted as good as my Nonna's homemade. The sauce is petite diced tomatoes well seasoned. Can't wait to have cold pizza and eggs for breakfast tomorrow.
S
Sarah J
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/27/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Gyro with extra sauce and a small fry. Gyro meat was really over cooked there were also crunchy bits which shouldn't be a thing in a Gyro of any kind. The
Hand-Tossed Holy Macaroni Pizza didn't look half as great in real life and such a small pizza for $18. bread sticks were okay and I ordered extra Feta but did not feel i got extra Feta on my Lamb & Beef Gyros. Also need to mention the tzatziki sauce was not great, I'd rate it a 5/10 versus homemade or well made sauce.
C
Corey H
6 contributions
Loved
• 10/28/25
• DoorDash order
the 5 Meat Pizza ann Jalapeno Poppers was fresh mouthwatering perfect portion for a family meal would order again
T
Travis O
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/2/24
• DoorDash order
18.00 for a 10 inch pizza seems extreme. I have ordered the same order before and the pizza at that cost was a large.
D
Dale M
Emerging Expert • 31 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/19/25
• DoorDash order
the wings were made with too much kind of sick and not very tasty I wish I wish there was an option for the traditional sauces on the side.
the potato wedges were overcooked.
they shorted me a can of soda and then gave me an extra bag of potato chips and I'm
Deli Extreme oitdtanding wish they would let you put more toppings like Olive, onions or other toppings but it was a very good sandwich.
I have been ordering from them for years generally but let me make mistake. they do have a great variety of food so you should be able to find something you like
