The Old Fashioned
4.6(100+)โข
DashPassโข
Americanโข
Store Infoโข
DashPass
Closed
Order now, get it later
4.6(100+)โข
$$โขAmerican
Full Menu
11:00โฏam - 4:35โฏpmFeatured Items
Opens 11:00โฏAM
Order for later
Featured Items
Door County Cherry Salad
$13.95
The Old Fashioned House Burger
$13.95
Walleye Sandwich
$15.95
โข85% (7)
#2 Most liked
Mac & Cheese
$15.95
Reuben
$13.95
โข85% (7)
#1 Most liked
Wisconsin Burger
$11.95
Reviews100+ ratings โข 8 public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
M
Marcia B
6 contributionsLiked
โข 8/3/26We ordered the Walleye Sandwich with fries, theWell's Farm Patty Melt, and the Wisconsin Burger with haystack onion for delivery thru Doordash. Even with the time from grill to delivery, everything was very good. Granted, we had to reheat for a hot minute but the flavor was excellent. Had not ordered from this establishment before, but it's definitely in our rotation now! ๐๐๐๐๐
J
Jennifer D
Emerging Expert โข 21 contributionsLiked
โข 3/19/26Best Double Brat in Madison by far. With fries and a side of tiger sauce? Untouchable.
J
Joseph S
1 contributionsLiked
โข 8/9/26Reuben was great. Sloppy Joe was served on a regular hamburger bun, mince felt a little overcooked but the fries are very good.
G
Gail G
2 contributionsDidn't like
โข 2/12/26Reubens and fries were extremely salty and corned beef was Sliced too thick and very hard to eat. food was delivered quickly though
L
Lydia S
3 contributionsDidn't like
โข 3/10/25the mac&cheese was underwhelming flavor wise. And the onion strings were not very crispy. Seasoning was bland all around.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Extra Dips
House-made dips perfect for dipping!