LUCILLE IS A FRESH COCKTAIL, CRAFT BEER, PIZZA, AND SHARED PLATTERS VENUE WITH THREE LEVELS. The First Settlement District of Madison, WI, is the gateway to Madison's historic culinary and entertainme…
Steel pan pizza (6 mile), was very good, as was the Empanada. Unfortunately the pizza is packed on a corrugated piece of paper or very thin card board, and all of the cut lines have cheese fused to the paper... so you pull up a piece and then have to spend time picking paper off the pizza. Hopefully they fix this!
P
Phil R
20 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/1/24
• DoorDash order
My second time ordering the Detroit pizza Its the second time I was disappointed. The last time I will order. The pizza was soggy and at $5.00 a topping and paying over $40.00 for a 3 topping pizza they were skimpy with large parts of the pizza being only cheese. The box had no type of seal and the sauce wasn even put in a bag ei time.
A
Angela G
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/17/25
• DoorDash order
the Cedar Grove Cheese Curds were a small portion and were incredibly greasy, worth maybe half the price. the 10" Build Your Own Wood-Fired Pizza was fine but nothing special
A
Alexa T
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/28/22
• DoorDash order
for some reason our steel pan pizza had very little cheese on it. maybe 1/4 of the pizza was covered in cheese? really only 2 good pieces in the whole pizza. we've generally liked pizzas we've gotten from the Lucille so this was super disappointing.
C
Crystal W
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/11/25
• DoorDash order
I wanted to like this place so much. But almost 40 dollars for a 9x10 pizza is absurd. The dough is light and buttery, but the bottom was so soft I had to throw it in the airfryer.
Verde salad was delicious, but again overpriced for what it is.
