We are motivated by the ancient Italian values of family, friends, and, of course, food at New York Pizza Elk Grove. With our fresh ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and traditional pizza-making techniq…
Second time ordering because the garlic sauce was so amazing the first time! Tonight, there was a mishap, and we got the wrong order. The staff was so amazing and fixed it right away. I can now say that they have great red sauce as well as garlic sauce. My new favorite pizza place! Garlic sauce is so good!!! No fear of vampires tonight!!!!
A
Amanda C
7 contributions
Loved
• 3/15/25
• DoorDash order
NY NY Combo (Large) is a classic, made just right. lots of tasty toppings. This is my 2nd time having their Garlic Lovers Pizza (Large) and I LOVED it. The sauce is delicious and the pizza actually has a fresh garlic flavor. most places garlic lovers is good but the garlic flavor is mildly turned up. This pizza had a ton of tasty garlicky flavor without being too much or gross. it was fantastic. I ate more when I was full, just because it was so delicious.
A
Alicia C
7 contributions
Loved
• 5/16/23
• DoorDash order
Ive been in Elk Grove for about 6 years and I have not been able to find my pizza spot... one of my fiancées cowork suggested New York Pizza and now we are in love with this place! The pizza tastes so dang good and the staff is super awesome! Our favorites so far is Canadian Bacon with pineapple or just a pepperoni and pepp, mushrooms and olives and we never order without getting the Cheesy Garlic Bread. You will not be disappointed with this place. Thanks yall!
L
Linda C
Local Expert • 56 contributions
Loved
• 4/8/23
• DoorDash order
I decided to try NY Pizza from a review by a customer. (James B, THANK YOU!!!!) So GLAD I did. WOW!!! Want to fill up? Get the sampler. Every single thing is tasty, well cooked and pair with a salad (next thing I am going to try) would be perfect. The NY Combo is just like it was described in the review. Fresh tasting, well cooked. Plenty of toppings. The sauce used is not acidic, but a wonderful aromatically cooked tomato sauce.
I agree, NY Pizza is my new place to shop.
M
Michael S
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/11/23
• DoorDash review
Crust was undercooked and the toppings were pretty underwhelming. Generic pizza box, delivered warm at best. The pepperoni pizza was only saved by the bacon crumbles put on top. You can do much better for the same price.
