Gumby's Pizza has created a solid reputation for high-quality food, outstanding customer service, and amazing pricing.Gumby's Pizza is known for its high-quality items, excellent service, and low pric…
The ice cream was delicious! Unfortunately they were out of both flavors we ordered and they didn't even tell us this. We discovered it after leaving with our items. My son took a bite and his was sherbet—which isn’t ice cream. An odd substitution to make but we thought ok we’ll just go back in and tell them we want to swap it. After getting inside I checked mine and it was chocolate, which I cannot eat. So I asked to swap mine for a non chocolate option like what I’d originally ordered. The girl got a bit snippy/huffy with us after that. But if they have to make substitutions they need to do better about reaching out to the customer to make them aware; if they can’t reach them then they should wait for them to come inside and inquire face to face. Barring those options, if you’re going to make a swap, make it a SIMILAR item; don’t change dairy for non-dairy or fruit for candy, etc. People have allergies, intolerances and preferences to consider. Beyond all of that, our experience was great.
J
Jon Y
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/16/26
• DoorDash order
Just another branch of gumby's pizza. The desert pizza is nothing close to something you might find a cece's or sicily's. Literally just pizza bread with chocolate drizzle and a little bit of powdered sugar. Small Dessert Pizza
J
Justin K
5 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/11/22
• DoorDash order
Shakes were extremely small, especially for 38$!! And they did not have the flavor I ordered and substituted it with something I'm allergic to, without bothering to call. I called the restaurant and they couldn't have cared less.
Foodiei '
Emerging Expert • 23 contributions
Didn't like
• 10/20/25
• DoorDash order
My Small Dessert Pizza came in a Gumby's pizza box so idk what that was all about and all I got was flavored bread sticks. They were fresh and tasted fair enough but this whole purchase felt very misleading and I won't order from here again.
M
Madeline C
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/4/24
• DoorDash order
milkshake is not at giant or worth 15$. maybe 6-7$. taste was fine but poorly packaged and not worth the price.
